The value of automobile insurance coverage fluctuates relying on quite a lot of elements — however one of many largest determinants of that worth is your age. Since teenagers and younger drivers are simply getting began behind the wheel, they’re sometimes the most expensive age cohort to insure.

On common, dad and mom can anticipate to see their annual insurance coverage invoice improve by $2,168 when including a 16-year-old driver to their full protection automobile insurance coverage coverage, according to Bankrate. To be clear, that is not the complete price however an added price. As compared, the common annual premium for full protection of a 40-year-old driver with a clear driving file and good credit score is $1,668. Plus, if a younger driver has a automobile accident or will get a ticket, insurance coverage costs can rise an additional 20% to 40%.

Given the astronomical pricing, we have compiled an inventory of carriers with stellar rankings that additionally provide strong reductions for younger drivers to assist deliver down your premium. All of our picks embrace accident forgiveness options and function in all 50 states plus Washington, DC, aside from Amica (which does not embrace protection in Hawaii).

Evaluate auto insurance coverage charges

Reply just a few inquiries to see customized charges from high carriers

Earlier than we dive in, listed here are some issues to bear in mind. 

What you could learn about insuring teenagers and younger drivers

Teen drivers are these within the 16-to-19 age vary, whereas younger grownup drivers are between 20 and 25. The most costly age group to insure are 16-year-olds. (Teen boys are usually concerned in additional serious auto accidents than others, and are extra expensive to insure.) Premiums typically lower every year a younger driver beneficial properties expertise behind the wheel. 

Should you’re a father or mother, as soon as your baby reaches 18, you may must resolve whether or not to buy a separate automobile insurance coverage coverage in your teen or have them listed in your insurance coverage.

“It’s virtually by no means inexpensive to have teenagers listed beneath their very own insurance coverage,” stated Michael Giusti, an analyst at “Nearly each metric used to price insurance coverage insurance policies will favor the dad and mom — credit score, age, driving historical past — so the bottom price of insurance coverage could be set, with the teenager as an add-on.”

Nonetheless, there are area of interest conditions the place it is likely to be higher for the teenager to be on their very own insurance coverage plan — like if they’ve a nasty driving historical past. 

“Placing the teenager on a separate coverage would not be inexpensive, however it will preserve that historical past from dragging down the dad and mom’ price,” Giusti stated.

How to economize on auto insurance coverage for teenagers

There are methods to chop down on insurance coverage premium coverage prices. For example, being a secure driver and utilizing extra environment friendly autos (reminiscent of Honda Civics, Toyota Priuses and Nissan Rogues) tends to chop prices, even for teen drivers, in line with Giusti. There are additionally reductions based mostly on how typically you employ your automobile: “Some corporations provide reductions to motorists who drive lower than the common variety of miles per 12 months,” says Janet Ruiz, director of strategic communication on the Insurance Information Institute.

Teenagers may additionally qualify for “good scholar” discounts, or reductions based mostly on studying secure driving habits from a defensive driving course or graduated driver licensing packages.

You may additionally be capable to get monetary savings if the youthful driver in your coverage is not utilizing their automobile as a result of they’re away at school. “If there’s a younger driver in your coverage who’s … away at school with no automobile you might also qualify for a decrease price,” in line with Ruiz. Each insurance coverage service gives totally different reductions relying in your protection possibility and different elements, so it pays to examine which of them apply to you earlier than signing up.

Finest automobile insurance coverage corporations for teenagers and younger adults

Geico made this listing for a similar purpose it topped our different finest lists. The service gives aggressive charges nationwide for younger drivers — the common annual added premium for full protection for a 16-year-old is $2,168, according to Bankrate. Furthermore, Geico has a low number of complaints, in line with the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners, or NAIC, along with excessive buyer satisfaction scores in line with J.D. Power Surveys

Geico’s strong reductions geared particularly to younger drivers make it an ideal possibility if you could deliver your premium down. This features a “good scholar” low cost for B averages or greater (save as much as 15%), a brand new car low cost (save as much as 15%), a multicar low cost (save as much as 25%) and driver low cost for younger adults who’ve gone 5 years accident-free (save as much as 22%). 

These are hefty reductions and what we love about Geico is its transparency on how a lot it can save you. Different insurers could let you know they provide reductions, however they do not reveal how a lot it can save you.

Read our Geico Auto Insurance review.



Most of us aren’t eligible for an insurance coverage coverage with the United Companies Vehicle Affiliation, however in case you’ve received a navy member or veteran within the household, then your teen driver might be able to get protection from this insurer.

USAA has made it onto our insurance coverage finest lists due to its nice customer support, in line with J.D. Energy. The service acquired an total rating of 884 and 909 in total buyer satisfaction and auto claims satisfaction, respectively. As compared, the nationwide averages are clocked in at 834 and 909, additionally respectively.

Besides, USAA gives aggressive pricing for individuals who qualify in comparison with different insurers — and making the most of reductions makes the charges much more aggressive. It gives the identical reductions as a lot of its opponents, together with for good college students and for drivers who take driver coaching programs. Teenagers who transition from a household coverage to their very own auto insurance coverage could qualify for as much as a 10% legacy low cost on their insurance coverage.

State Farm is one other service with extensive availability throughout the US and a full spectrum of reductions for younger drivers. State Farm’s Drive Secure & Save app, which displays your driving habits, may show you how to save as much as 30%. State Farm additionally has a program out there to teenagers and younger adults known as Steer Clear, which permits the chance to benefit from reductions whereas educating your baby easy methods to drive safely.

Furthermore, drivers beneath 25 who’ve had no at-fault accidents or transferring violations for 3 years may save as much as 15%, which qualifies you for this low cost a lot faster than with Geico. And in case you’ve received a scholar at school who solely makes use of their automobile whereas at house on trip or holidays, you qualify for a “scholar away in school” low cost. 

In comparison with different insurers on this listing, State Farm’s reductions for younger drivers are fairly beefy, which is nice contemplating that the common annual added premium for full protection for a 16-year-old is $2,077, according to Bankrate


Everybody is aware of Flo from Progressive, however do you know she additionally has a Twitter account with greater than 71,000 followers? That is greater than twice the Twitter following for Geico’s unnamed gecko. Together with Flo’s fame, Progressive touts a low variety of complaints nationally. The NAIC’s index scored Progressive at 1.45 out of 1.00 (above one means extra complaints). Moreover, the common annual added premium for full protection for a 16-year-old is $3,305, which is decrease than the nationwide common by greater than $500.

Progressive has a collection of reductions for households with a number of autos in addition to for each teen motorists and faculty college students. Teen drivers who’re 18 years previous or youthful and have been insured for at the least 12 months can qualify for a “teen driver low cost.” Additionally, along with the usual “good scholar” low cost, Progressive cuts the worth for college students who depart their automobiles at house whereas attending college greater than 100 miles away, and for individuals who hardly ever drive.

Amica made it on our greatest automobile insurance coverage listing due to its excessive buyer satisfaction scores – and that is one of many causes it additionally makes this listing. Because the oldest mutual automobile insurer within the US (which means it is owned by its policyholders), Amica has over a century of trade know-how beneath its belt. This service additionally operates in all states besides Hawaii.

Together with commonplace choices for younger drivers — together with “good scholar” reductions, “scholar away in school” reductions and defensive driver coaching course reductions — Amica supplies a novel option to save: a legacy low cost. This low cost will apply for younger drivers beneath 30 whose dad and mom have had a automobile coverage with Amica for at the least 5 years. Furthermore, like State Farm, younger drivers who’ve been accident-free for 3 years may additionally get a reduction, which suggests they might qualify as early as 19 years previous. 

Finest automobile insurance coverage for teenagers and younger drivers, in contrast

Firm Reductions for younger drivers* A.M. Finest Monetary Power Ranking**
Geico Good scholar, new car, multi-car, good driver A++
USAA Good scholar, defensive driving coaching, legacy A++
State Farm Drive Secure & Save, Steer Clear, accident free, scholar away in school A++
Progressive Multi-vehicle, teen driver low cost, good scholar, scholar away in school A+
Amica Good scholar, scholar away in school, defensive driver coaching, legacy A+

*Not an exhaustive listing

**A.M. Finest monetary energy ranking scale runs from D (lowest) to A++ (highest).


How do you choose the most effective protection?

The most effective protection for you’ll handle your particular auto protection wants whereas becoming into your price range. For younger grownup drivers, auto insurance coverage tends to be dearer, so discovering a coverage with accident forgiveness, low charges or a number of reductions is vital.

What’s accident forgiveness?

Accident forgiveness is a automobile insurance coverage characteristic that forestalls your insurance coverage charges from growing following your first at-fault accident. Every service handles accident forgiveness in a different way, and so whereas some carriers could offer you this characteristic as a free bonus, others may make it an add-on to your coverage you must pay for. Furthermore, accident forgiveness will not be out there in all states, however that will depend on the service, too.

All the picks on this listing embrace some kind of accident forgiveness. Here is a breakdown of every:

  • Geico: Accident forgiveness is out there for drivers who’ve been accident-free for 5 years or extra, or you may improve your coverage by buying the characteristic. It isn’t out there in California, Connecticut or Massachusetts. 
  • USAA: Like Geico, you may unlock USAA’s accident forgiveness characteristic without cost in case your family has gone 5 years accident-free. Alternatively, you could possibly buy the choice. It isn’t out there in Connecticut, Delaware, North Caroline, California or New York.
  • State Farm: To qualify for State Farm’s accident forgiveness, you should have been at State Farm and have gone accident-free for 9 years. 
  • Progressive: This service gives two accident forgiveness choices. “Small Accident Forgiveness” comes along with your coverage, and it will cowl you if the whole declare is lower than or equal to $500. “Giant Accident Forgiveness” is out there to prospects who’ve stayed with Progressive for at the least 5 years and stay accident and moving-violation-free for at the least three consecutive years.
  • Amica: Amica has two choices for accident forgiveness, one free and one you should buy. Accident forgiveness mechanically comes with Amica’s Platinum Alternative Auto bundle, their premium tier protection. Alternatively, you may earn accident forgiveness by incomes “Benefit Factors.” Two methods to obtain these factors is by referring others to Amica or renewing an current coverage.

With such selection, it is vital to learn the positive print and, when you have one, ask your insurance coverage agent about accident forgiveness earlier than signing a coverage.

Why is insurance coverage so costly for teenage boys?

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the motorized vehicle dying price for teen males aged 16 to 19 was over two instances extra seemingly in comparison with feminine drivers of the identical age. This, mixed with teenagers’ common inexperience behind the wheel, is what drives up insurance coverage premiums for teen males, the costliest driving cohort to insure.

CNET critiques insurance coverage carriers and merchandise by exhaustively evaluating them throughout set standards developed for every class. For auto insurance coverage, we look at common annual premium charges for full protection, out there reductions for teenagers and younger drivers, shopper complaints, collision restore scores, the service’s monetary energy, auto claims satisfaction and total buyer satisfaction. Our knowledge comes from a large number of sources. 

Auto insurance coverage charges come from Bankrate, which gathers knowledge utilizing Quadrant Data Companies. We additionally use each J.D. Energy annual surveys that acquire knowledge on buyer auto claims satisfaction and total buyer satisfaction.

Shopper complaints are taken from the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners, which collects shopper complaints throughout states, indexing complaints on a scale that takes under consideration the trade common. We acquire the monetary energy ranking of every service from the A.M. Finest Ranking. Lastly, we collected collision restore scores from the Crash Community Insurer Report Card, which collects knowledge from collision restore professionals, together with mechanics, to gauge the standard of collision claims service from insurance coverage carriers.

For this listing, we additionally investigated out there reductions for teenagers and younger drivers. If a service was clear about how a lot it can save you from these reductions earlier than needing to get a quote, we thought-about {that a} plus. 

Extra automobile insurance coverage recommendation

The editorial content material on this web page relies solely on goal, impartial assessments by our writers and isn’t influenced by promoting or partnerships. It has not been offered or commissioned by any third get together. Nonetheless, we could obtain compensation if you click on on hyperlinks to services or products supplied by our companions.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here